Nutrify miễn phí 7 ngàyBắt đầu miễn phí
Logo NutrifyNutrify

Plant-Based Protein Powders Compared: Pea, Rice, Soy, Hemp

By Nutrify Team•Published on November 2, 2026•Weight Loss & Dieting#vegan#protein
Plant-Based Protein Powders Compared: Pea, Rice, Soy, Hemp

For most people, pea protein or a pea and rice blend is the best plant-based protein powder: a 30 g scoop of pea isolate gives about 24 g of protein, versus about 15 g from hemp. Soy isolate is just as good if you tolerate soy. Hemp is a nutritious add-in, but a weak main protein source.

All amino acid numbers below come from one lab analysis that tested the major plant isolates side by side (Gorissen et al., 2018), so they compare fairly. Your tub will differ a little, so check the label.

Key takeaways

  • Most protein per scoop: pea and brown rice isolates (about 80% and 79% protein). Hemp is about 51%.
  • Leucine, the muscle-building trigger: about 7% of protein for pea, rice and soy, 5% for hemp, versus about 11% for whey.
  • Blends make sense: pea is low in methionine, rice is low in lysine, and together they balance out.
  • Matching whey: you need about 38 g of pea protein (48 g of powder) to get the leucine in 25 g of whey protein.
  • Check for testing: plant powders tested higher for lead than dairy powders in Consumer Reports' 2025 tests.

Plant protein powders compared

Values per isolate from Gorissen et al. 2018, as reported in the paper's text or worked out from its Tables 1 and 2. "Per 30 g scoop" is calculated from the protein content; commercial products vary.

PowderProtein (% of powder)Protein per 30 g scoop (g)Leucine (% of protein)Weakest amino acidBest for
Pea isolate80247.1Methionine (0.4% of protein)Muscle building, all-round use
Brown rice isolate79247.3Lysine (2.4% of protein)Blending with pea, allergy-friendly
Soy isolate73 (61-91 by supplier)226.8Methionine (0.4% of protein)Muscle building if soy is fine for you
Hemp protein51155.1Lysine (2.8% of protein)Fiber and fat, smoothies
Potato isolate80248.3None below requirementsRare, usually in blends
Whey (for comparison)782310.8NoneReference point

PDCAAS, the classic protein-quality score, tells a similar story. Soy protein isolates score 1.00 (or 0.95-1.00, depending on the lab) on PDCAAS, where 1.00 is the maximum. Hemp seed meal scores 0.46-0.51 and dehulled hemp seed 0.63-0.66, with lysine as the limiting amino acid.

How much plant protein matches 25 g of whey?

Leucine is the amino acid that switches on muscle protein synthesis most strongly. The ISSN recommends 700-3,000 mg of leucine per protein dose. Because plant isolates contain less leucine than whey, you need a larger serving to get the same amount.

ProteinProtein needed to match the leucine in 25 g whey protein (g)Powder needed (g)
Whey2532
Potato3341
Brown rice3747
Pea3848
Soy4055
Hemp54105

In practice, one heaping scoop of pea or rice protein (about 1.5 standard scoops) lands you in the same place as one scoop of whey. With hemp, matching whey isn't realistic, which is why hemp works better as a supplement to other protein than as the main source.

Pea protein

Pea protein is made from yellow split peas. It has the best mix of protein density, leucine and lysine among the common plant powders, and it is the most studied for training.

  • Strengths: about 80% protein, 7.1% leucine, rich in lysine (5.9% of protein).
  • Weak spot: very low methionine. Pair it with rice protein or eat grains, nuts and seeds during the day.
  • Allergy note: pea isn't one of the nine major US food allergens, but pea and legume allergies exist.
  • Taste: mild and slightly earthy; it blends smoother in flavored products than plain.

In a 12-week trial, 161 men took 25 g of pea protein, whey protein or placebo twice a day while lifting. Biceps thickness grew in every group with no significant difference between pea and whey. Among the participants who were weakest at the start, pea beat placebo, while whey didn't differ significantly from either.

Brown rice protein

Rice protein is about as protein-dense as pea and has slightly more leucine, but it is low in lysine.

  • Strengths: about 79% protein, 7.3% leucine, the most methionine of the plant isolates (2.5% of protein).
  • Weak spot: lysine at 2.4% of protein, less than half of pea's.
  • Good for: people avoiding soy, legumes and dairy. Its flavor is the most neutral.

In an 8-week study of 24 trained men, 48 g of rice protein isolate after training improved body composition as much as 48 g of whey isolate.

Soy protein

Soy isolate is the original plant protein powder and the only common one with decades of sports research behind it.

  • Strengths: PDCAAS of 1.00 and a meta-analysis of 9 trials (266 people) found soy produced the same strength and lean mass gains as whey or other animal proteins.
  • Weak spot: soy is one of the nine major US food allergens.
  • The hormone question: a 2021 meta-analysis of 41 clinical studies found no effect of soy protein or isoflavones on testosterone, free testosterone, estradiol or estrone in men, regardless of dose or study length.

Hemp protein

Hemp protein is ground from pressed hemp seeds, so it keeps more of the seed's fiber and fat.

  • Strengths: fiber, omega-3 ALA and minerals that isolates lose. It tastes nutty and earthy.
  • Weak spots: only about 51% protein, 5.1% leucine, low lysine, and its essential amino acid content (23% of protein) falls below the WHO/FAO requirement.
  • Good for: smoothies and oatmeal when you want extra fiber. For protein targets, combine it with pea, soy or other sources.

Pea and rice blends

Most plant protein blends combine pea and rice, often around 70% pea and 30% rice. The logic is the lysine and methionine swap:

Amino acid (% of protein)PeaBrown riceWhat a blend does
Lysine5.92.4Pea fills rice's gap
Methionine0.42.5Rice fills pea's gap
Leucine7.17.3Similar either way

Some blends add potato, faba bean or pumpkin seed protein. Potato protein is the only plant isolate in the Gorissen analysis that met every essential amino acid requirement, but it is less common and usually appears as one ingredient in a blend.

Can plant protein build muscle as well as whey?

Yes, when the dose is big enough. Pea (12 weeks, 161 men), rice (8 weeks, 24 men) and soy (9-trial meta-analysis) all produced gains similar to whey. A small 8-week study of 15 high-intensity functional training athletes taking 24 g of whey or pea protein before and after training also found no differences.

The difference shows up per gram, not in the end result. Plant powders need a larger scoop to match whey's leucine, and total daily protein matters more than the powder. The ISSN recommends 1.4-2.0 g of protein per kg of body weight per day for people who train, with 20-40 g per meal or shake. Find your number with the protein calculator, and see the full head-to-head in whey vs plant protein.

Heavy metals in plant protein powder

Plants can take up lead and other metals from soil, and some of it ends up in powders. In October 2025, Consumer Reports tested 23 protein powders and ready-to-drink shakes:

  • More than two-thirds had more lead in one serving than CR's daily level of concern (0.5 micrograms, based on California's Proposition 65 limit).
  • Plant-based powders averaged about nine times the lead of dairy-based powders and twice that of beef-based ones.
  • There are no federal limits on heavy metals in supplements. The Council for Responsible Nutrition, an industry group, says going over CR's threshold isn't the same as exceeding a government safety limit.

What to do with that: choose powders with third-party testing (NSF Certified for Sport, Informed Choice or Informed Sport), use powder to fill gaps rather than as your main protein, and get most of your protein from food. Our complete guide to vegan protein sources lists the best whole-food options. If you're pregnant or buying protein for a child, talk to your doctor first.

How to choose a plant-based protein powder

  1. Protein per serving: look for at least 20 g. Below 15 g, you're paying for filler or a low-protein source like hemp.
  2. Source: pea, soy or a pea and rice blend for muscle; hemp for fiber.
  3. Third-party testing: a seal from NSF, Informed Choice or Informed Sport, or published heavy metal results.
  4. Short ingredient list: protein, flavor, a sweetener, maybe a gum. Watch for added sugar in flavored tubs.
  5. Calories per scoop: plain isolates are mostly protein, but flavored blends with sugar, oils or creamers can carry far more calories. Check how a shake fits your day in protein shake calories.

For a full plant-based week, the vegan meal prep weekly plan shows how powder fits around real meals. Nutrify can log a scoop by barcode and the rest of your meals by photo; it has a 7-day free trial, then a paid subscription.

Sources

Câu hỏi thường gặp

Tìm câu trả lời cho các câu hỏi phổ biến

  • For most people, pea protein or a pea and rice blend gives the most protein per scoop and the best amino acid balance. Soy isolate is equally good if you aren't allergic. Hemp is better as a whole-food add-in than as a main protein source.

  • For protein, yes. A pea isolate is about 80% protein with about 7% leucine, while hemp protein is about 51% protein with 5% leucine, so a 30 g scoop gives roughly 24 g of protein from pea versus 15 g from hemp. Hemp brings more fiber and fat.

  • They cover each other's weak spots. Pea is rich in lysine but low in methionine, and brown rice is the reverse, so a blend has a more complete amino acid profile than either alone.

  • In training studies, pea, rice and soy protein produced muscle and strength gains similar to whey when doses were large enough. Because plant proteins have less leucine, you need a bigger scoop, about 38 g of pea protein to match the leucine in 25 g of whey protein.

  • No. A 2021 meta-analysis of 41 clinical studies found that soy protein and soy isoflavones didn't change testosterone or estrogen levels in men, at any dose or study length.

  • Some do. In Consumer Reports' October 2025 tests of 23 products, plant-based powders averaged about nine times more lead than dairy-based ones. Choose brands with third-party testing and rotate protein sources rather than relying on one powder every day.

  • Aim for 20-40 g of protein per serving, at the higher end for plant powders, as part of 1.4-2.0 g of protein per kg of body weight per day if you train. That usually means 1 to 1.5 scoops, depending on the label.

Nutrify Team's avatar

Nutrify Team

A team of nutrition experts, developers, and health enthusiasts dedicated to making healthy living accessible to everyone.

Track this in Nutrify

Free to download on iOS and Android. Everything below is part of the app.

Theo dõi Nutrify trên Google

Thêm Nutrify làm nguồn ưa thích để thấy nhiều hướng dẫn dinh dưỡng của chúng tôi hơn trong kết quả Google.